Can Hit and Run Charges be dropped in California?
Being charged with a hit-and-run in California is a frightening experience that can threaten your freedom, your finances, and your future. Many drivers wonder if these charges can be dropped or reduced before they cause permanent damage to their record. At Rubin Law, P.C., we specialize in aggressive defense strategies designed to protect your rights and help you move forward.
Understanding California Hit-and-Run Laws
In California, hit-and-run charges are categorized based on whether the accident caused property damage or physical injury. Knowing which statute you are facing is the first step in building a defense.
Misdemeanor Hit and Run (Vehicle Code 20002)
A misdemeanor charge occurs when a driver leaves the scene of an accident that resulted in property damage only. This includes hitting a parked car, a fence, or even a pet. The law requires you to stop and exchange information or leave a visible note if the owner is not present.
- Standard Penalties: Up to six months in county jail, fines up to $1,000, and two points on your DMV record.
Felony Hit and Run (Vehicle Code 20001)
If an accident involves injury or death, the charge can be elevated to a felony. This is considered a “wobbler,” meaning a prosecutor can choose to charge it as a misdemeanor or a felony depending on the severity of the injury and the defendant’s criminal history.
- Severe Consequences: For serious or permanent injuries, penalties include up to four years in state prison and fines reaching $10,000.
The “Pre-Filing” Window: Stopping Charges Before They Start
One of the most effective ways to have hit-and-run charges “dropped” is to prevent them from being filed in the first place. This is known as Pre-Filing Intervention.
When an accident is reported, there is a gap between the police investigation and the District Attorney’s decision to file formal charges. During this window, Rubin Law, P.C. works directly with law enforcement and investigators. By presenting mitigating evidence or highlighting flaws in the police report early, we can often persuade the prosecution to decline the case or “reject” the filing entirely. This keeps your record clean without ever having to step foot in a courtroom.
Can a “Civil Compromise” Still Get Your Charges Dismissed?
For years, the “Civil Compromise” was the primary way to get a misdemeanor hit-and-run dismissed. Under Penal Code 1377, if you paid the victim for their property damage and they agreed not to prosecute, the judge could dismiss the case.
The 2026 Reality
However, recent California case law—specifically the ruling in People v. Dimacali—has made this much harder. The courts have ruled that the “crime” of a hit-and-run is not the accident itself, but the act of fleeing the scene. Because fleeing the scene is a crime against the public, a private payment to a victim doesn’t automatically satisfy the law’s requirements. While a Civil Compromise is no longer a “guarantee” for dismissal, it remains a powerful tool that Rubin Law, P.C. uses to show the court that you have taken responsibility, which often leads to reduced charges.
Beyond “Civil Compromise”: New Paths to Dismissal
Since the rules for Civil Compromise have tightened, our firm utilizes modern legal pathways that many other attorneys overlook.
Judicial Diversion (PC 1001.95)
Under California’s judicial diversion law, a judge can “pause” your case for up to two years. If you complete certain requirements—such as community service or a safe driving course—the judge must dismiss the charges. The best part? This can be granted even if the prosecutor objects.
Mental Health Diversion (PC 1001.36)
If the act of leaving the scene was influenced by a mental health condition, such as PTSD, extreme anxiety, or a panic attack, you may qualify for Mental Health Diversion.
- How it works: Instead of jail, you receive court-approved treatment.
- The Result: Upon successful completion, the charges are dismissed and the arrest is “deemed to have never occurred.”
Top Defenses to Fight a Hit-and-Run Charge
1. Lack of Knowledge
You cannot be convicted of a hit-and-run if you truly did not know an accident happened. This is common in low-impact collisions or when driving a large vehicle where a small bump isn’t felt.
2. Mistaken Identity & Digital Alibis
Just because your car was involved doesn’t mean you were driving. We use “Digital Alibis”—such as cell phone GPS data, Google Timeline history, or timestamped receipts—to prove you were elsewhere at the time of the crash.
3. Constitutional Violations: Challenging the Stop
At Rubin Law, P.C., we scrutinize the way police gathered evidence. If the police stopped your car without reasonable suspicion or searched your property without a warrant, we can file a motion to suppress that evidence. If the evidence is thrown out, the prosecution usually has no choice but to drop the charges.
4. The “Safety Exception”
California law recognizes that sometimes it is unsafe to stop. If you fled the scene because you were being threatened by the other driver or felt your life was in danger, this can serve as a valid legal defense.
The Statute of Limitations: How Long Can They Wait?
The state does not have forever to charge you.
- Misdemeanors: Generally, the prosecution must file charges within one year.
- Felonies: For injury cases, the window is usually three years, though this can vary based on when the crime was “discovered.”
If the prosecution misses these deadlines, Rubin Law, P.C. can file a “Serna Motion” to have your case dismissed due to a violation of your right to a speedy trial.
Critical Mistakes That Prevent Charges From Being Dropped
Avoiding a conviction often depends on what you don’t do.
- Talking to Insurance: Your insurance company is not your lawyer. Statements you make to them can be subpoenaed by the police and used to prove you knew about the accident.
- Admitting Fault to Police: Never speak to detectives without an attorney. Even a simple “I’m sorry” can be used as a confession of guilt.
- Delaying Restitution: Waiting until your court date to address damages makes you look uncooperative. Strategic, attorney-led restitution can be the difference between a dismissal and jail time.
Why You Need Rubin Law, P.C.
We understand that one bad decision shouldn’t ruin your life. Rubin Law, P.C. provides the high-level technical defense needed to navigate California’s complex hit-and-run statutes. From challenging DNA evidence on airbags to negotiating with the District Attorney’s elite units, we fight to get your life back on track.
Frequently Asked Questions (People Also Ask)
1. Can a hit-and-run be dropped if I was not at fault for the accident? Yes, but remember that fault in the crash is separate from the “crime” of leaving. Even if the other person hit you, you are legally required to stop. However, our firm uses the other driver’s fault as leverage to argue for a dismissal.
2. How long does a hit-and-run investigation take in California? Investigations can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months. The police often wait for witness statements or camera footage before making an arrest.
3. Will I lose my license if the charges are reduced? A hit-and-run conviction adds 2 points to your record. If those points put you over the limit, the DMV will suspend your license. By getting charges reduced to a non-moving violation, we can often save your driving privileges.
4. Can I be charged if I hit an animal? Yes. Under VC 20002, hitting a domestic animal (like a dog) is considered property damage. You must attempt to find the owner or notify the police/animal control.
5. What is the “2-point” trap? Even if a criminal judge dismisses your case, the DMV is a separate entity. You must win your DMV administrative hearing to prevent the points from hitting your record. We handle both the court and the DMV for our clients.
Contact Rubin Law, P.C. Today
Don’t wait for a knock on your door from the police. If you are under investigation or have already been charged with a hit-and-run in California, you need an expert strategist in your corner.
The post Can Hit and Run Charges be dropped in California? appeared first on Rubin Law, PC.
from Rubin Law, PC https://rubinlawpc.com/can-hit-and-run-charges-be-dropped-in-california/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=can-hit-and-run-charges-be-dropped-in-california
via Rubin Law, P.C.
Comments
Post a Comment